There has been some interesting action around these parts while I have been away. It started with some exchanges between Jacob and Mogget about the general subject of theology. Late in one of those threads at Mogget made an interesting comment:
Two points about our info on the post-mortal existence:
If it’s something that is known only by revelation, then let’s admit that it’s so.
If we’re going to speculate about it, then it needs structure and organization.
Now it seems that there are folks that think three kingdoms, and folks that think “many kingdoms.†Interestingly enough, both sides seem to think they have logic, exegesis, and revelation on their side.
So let’s take a step back in the whole process and talk about how to distinguish between competing claims in general before we work on this issue. It would seem that the tough one is competing claims of revelation, no?
Anybody got any ideas? Something reasonably objective?
The point she brings up about competing revelations a difficult but highly important one. (more…)